Valuable Lincoln Wheat Pennies Still in Circulation : The Lincoln Wheat Penny (1909-1958) remains one of America’s most collected coins. While millions were minted, a few rare versions can be worth thousands. The most sought-after include the 1909-S VDB (with designer initials), the 1943 copper penny (accidentally struck on wrong metal), and the 1955 doubled die error. These can fetch $100,000+ in top condition.
To identify valuable pennies
- Check dates (1909, 1943, 1955) and mint marks (“S” for San Francisco)
- Look for doubling in lettering or dates
- Weigh 1943 pennies (copper ones are heavier)
- Examine condition – sharp details and minimal wear increase value
Though rare, these coins still surface in unexpected places. Some are found in inherited collections, old coin rolls from banks, or even everyday change. A New Jersey man reportedly found a 1943 copper penny in his lunch money in 2017 that later sold for $200,000.
For potential finds
- Never clean coins – it reduces value
- Handle carefully by the edges
- Get professional authentication from PCGS or NGC
- Check completed eBay sales for realistic values
While the odds are slim, the possibility makes checking wheat pennies exciting. Even common dates in excellent condition can be worth $5-$50, making them worth a second look. The thrill of the hunt keeps collectors searching pocket change decades after these pennies last entered circulation.